Hobie Forums http://www.hobie.com/au/en/forums/ |
|
What's the deal with a forum "warning"? http://www.hobie.com/au/en/forums/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=62917 |
Page 1 of 2 |
Author: | kross57 [ Thu Jun 07, 2018 8:30 pm ] |
Post subject: | What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
I just received a strange message from Hobie: "This is a warning regarding the following post made by you: viewtopic.php?f=11&p=301824#p301824 . This is really getting old. I am not going to put up with blatant Hobie bashing in multiple forum topics on this site. This is kinda getting to be like your old days in the KFS forums. You and Riddler... geeze. What you are doing is evident to other forums users as well and they too are bored with the attitude." I looked over the forums for any kind of policy or explanation of the forum rules, what a warning is, and so on. Nothing I can find. I also took a look at the Hobie "product support" page. This is what it says: "Product Support Our dealers are experts and the best source of support for your Hobie product. For more help, browse our support resources below, or get ideas and solutions from other owners and Hobie staff in the forums." Clearly, Hobie made the forums a part of their product support, and intended the flow of information, not only between Hobie staff, but between and from "other owners" as well. I'm sure that things like personal attacks can't be tolerated. But product negatives should certainly be open to discussion. And any attempt by moderators to limit that discussion must be done with extreme care since this is part of their product support. If we are encouraged to "get ideas" are these to be restricted to only those ideas that the forum moderators like? If anyone has info, please share it. |
Author: | mmiller [ Fri Jun 08, 2018 8:44 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
Kross57 You understand where the warning I sent comes from. The purpose of our forums is to share information... Helpful. Productive. Constructive. Informative. Complaints are welcome as well. We learn a lot from forum feedback, but constant negativity is not reasonable or acceptable. |
Author: | kross57 [ Fri Jun 08, 2018 11:04 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
Discussing flaws in kayaks is not negative, it is either opinion based on experience, or simple fact. Whether it is positive or negative depends on your point of view. A complaint can be helpful, productive, constructive,, and informative. They are not a separate item, as you seem to think. Quite frankly, from my viewpoint, the most negativity I see is from you. If I have broken any forum rules, which ones? Where are they stated? I would be happy to follow them, if only they existed. Please point them out for all of us. For the record, constant negativity would mean that I have never said anything positive. Is that your position? As I told you in a private message, I will be taking this up with the Hobie company. I hope to get some solid answers there. Your comments make no sense. |
Author: | mmiller [ Fri Jun 08, 2018 12:27 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
Quote: A complaint can be helpful, productive, constructive, and informative. Totally agree as I stated... Quote: The purpose of our forums is to share information... Helpful. Productive. Constructive. Informative. Complaints are welcome as well. We learn a lot from forum feedback
|
Author: | Pescatoral Pursuit [ Fri Jun 08, 2018 12:35 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
Whether or not I agree with the course of action that Hobie takes concerning yours or other's complaints, I think in general they're very candid about allowing criticisms of their product to remain on their boards until that criticism takes a certain tone, whether or not that tone becomes exacerbated by say certain ludicrous fan boy retorts. Personally, I would not tolerate it past a certain point either. |
Author: | oldyaker [ Fri Jun 08, 2018 4:11 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
I`ve noticed that folks are more irritable these days than saaay 20 years ago. Is it too many pollutants in the air? Hate to see what it will be 20 years from now. I do ok until another kayak gets right behind me. ![]() |
Author: | Tom Kirkman [ Fri Jun 08, 2018 7:08 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
Obviously, constructive criticism is helpful to any company that wishes constant and continued product improvement. There is no better path to improvement that the experience that comes from the users of a product. However... during the normal course of forum participation, you would expect the comments from product users to run the gamut from praise, enjoyment, questions, experience and yes, even criticism, to be found in somewhat equal amounts. When a member's comments are almost uniquely critical to a fault, it is not outside the bounds and common sense of any company to reign in such participation. |
Author: | oldyaker [ Fri Jun 08, 2018 8:43 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
This gentle man is a genius. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SNzLB8-ghvw Drop the mic. |
Author: | kross57 [ Sat Jun 09, 2018 3:13 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
And, if we get rid of what seems like your hostility, we now have a discussion. What's wrong with that? I NEVER said I was absolutely right about everything. And I can change my mind if someone has a compelling reason for me to do so. That is NOT bashing, or bitterness. That's a valid exchange. So, as far as the warranty issues, I will look into the points you made and respond. In fact, in the next few weeks I will take every one of the issues I raised - hatch leaks, handling without the rudder, soft plastic, hull cracks, warranty - and explain my concerns in detail. I will be happy to consider and discuss alternate points of view and different opinions. Again, what could be wrong with that? My suggestion is to keep right on posting your views, while keeping in mind that none of us knows all there is to know about Hobie kayaks. |
Author: | fusioneng [ Sat Jun 09, 2018 7:30 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
I just found a cool feature in the forum settings called friend/foe settings under options. Hypothetically speaking here if someone were to have a ‘personal extremely strong total loathing distain’ for some hypothetical member on the forum, for example, you can always go into settings. I’m not suggesting anything here, just highlighting a cool forum feature I just stumbled on to, that’s all. FE Edit: I meant to say ‘un-empathetic’ in quotes above, sorry for the grammer mistake. |
Author: | jeffreydc [ Sat Jun 09, 2018 7:41 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
Roadrunner NAILED it on the head! This Kross character is a real pain in the arse. I can only imagine what it would be like having to deal with him as a customer. Its not just that he has bashed Hobie and their products relentlessly but he has attacked several forum members on a personal level as well. He called Fusioneng ignorant...really...Fusioneng??? I dont even know Fusioneng but i have been on this forum for several years and I cant imagine a more decent down to earth and intelligent guy then Fusion! This DBag should sell all his Hobie "crap" and move on to greener pastures. |
Author: | jclarkdawe [ Sun Jun 10, 2018 4:47 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
kross57 -- You do understand that warranties are marketing tools? Any company knows they will make mistakes and reputable companies will fix those problems. Any company also knows that some people will try them on with questionable claims. You want a warranty that covers the first and denies the second and is written in a way to attract customers. Most customers understand this equation and will accept, maybe not happily but will accept, the decision of the company. A certain percentage of customers won't accept that the company doesn't cover everything. For a recent company discussing warranty issues, take a look at L.L. Bean. For example, any product left in the sun will deteriorate. Guess what happens with any boat? It's out in the sun, in a brutal environment, and it will eventually fail. No company will promise a lifetime, unlimited warranty. It might end up later, but they will go broke at some point. Some people don't understand that sun damage can occur very quickly even if the manufacturer does everything right if the product receives no protection. Pointing out that some Hobie products fail is no more meaningful than pointing out that some cars break, some planes break, and my list could go on forever. Pointing out that sometimes Hobie will not cover the costs of repair to that product is also not meaningful. To assume that all claims are Hobie's responsibility is illogical. Some people don't take care of the things they buy. I don't want to buy a product where I'm paying for those people to have their product fixed. It's going to cost more. You should read warranties before you buy. If you don't like Hobie's warranty, why did you buy the product? I'm a moderator on another site. We have posters like you that do not provide any benefit to the community. If I was in Matt's position on this forum, I'd be thinking of banning you. Web sites are not free, but are paid for by their owners. The owner has the right to impose restrictions, even if they are not reasonable. Your goal here seems to be mainly to bash Hobie. Why should Hobie let you? Jim Clark-Dawe |
Author: | kross57 [ Sun Jun 10, 2018 7:46 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: What's the deal with a forum "warning"? |
jclarkdawe wrote: kross57 -- You do understand that warranties are marketing tools? Any company knows they will make mistakes and reputable companies will fix those problems. Any company also knows that some people will try them on with questionable claims. You want a warranty that covers the first and denies the second and is written in a way to attract customers. Most customers understand this equation and will accept, maybe not happily but will accept, the decision of the company. A certain percentage of customers won't accept that the company doesn't cover everything. For a recent company discussing warranty issues, take a look at L.L. Bean. For example, any product left in the sun will deteriorate. Guess what happens with any boat? It's out in the sun, in a brutal environment, and it will eventually fail. No company will promise a lifetime, unlimited warranty. It might end up later, but they will go broke at some point. Some people don't understand that sun damage can occur very quickly even if the manufacturer does everything right if the product receives no protection. Pointing out that some Hobie products fail is no more meaningful than pointing out that some cars break, some planes break, and my list could go on forever. Pointing out that sometimes Hobie will not cover the costs of repair to that product is also not meaningful. To assume that all claims are Hobie's responsibility is illogical. Some people don't take care of the things they buy. I don't want to buy a product where I'm paying for those people to have their product fixed. It's going to cost more. You should read warranties before you buy. If you don't like Hobie's warranty, why did you buy the product? I'm a moderator on another site. We have posters like you that do not provide any benefit to the community. If I was in Matt's position on this forum, I'd be thinking of banning you. Web sites are not free, but are paid for by their owners. The owner has the right to impose restrictions, even if they are not reasonable. Your goal here seems to be mainly to bash Hobie. Why should Hobie let you? Jim Clark-Dawe Jim, I appreciate the response. as far as why I purchased a Hobie, I researched them pretty well. Reliability is key for me, so I was concerned about their reputation for hull cracks. But I was assured that this issue had been corrected and they were a thing of the past. My mistake. In my past experience hull failures are extremely rare and anything else that might go wrong is a cheap fix. But my point about the short warranty is not that it was a surprise. I was pointing out that covering a defective hull for five or six years is pretty much an industry standard. Nothing wonderful about that. To answer your other question, Hobie lists these forms as a part of their product support. The notion that customers would only use such support as a way of complimenting Hobie is quite bizarre. Yet, apparently, I can be chastised for listing product flaws but calling me a dbag is fine. Strange way of running a product support forum. One might think they were trying to prevent any mention of kayak flaws. I still fail to see how describing product flaws is bashing. Lots of companies accept online reviews of their products, good or bad. And they somehow survive. Just one more point. I am extremely pleased that folks take things like faulty cars and plane crashes seriously. To me those are kind of important. |
Page 1 of 2 | All times are UTC - 8 hours [ DST ] |
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |