jmecky wrote:
Now I'm screwed, look at this and tell me what went wrong, and what should I do to fix it.
Dang! I hate that! I feel a "Previous Owner" rant coming on, but I'm going to hold back
This is precisely why one should always use what the boat was made of to do the repair. I guarantee that some previous owner (PO) coated those suckers with a rattle can. Probably looked good for a couple of years for them. Then you come along and think all is right with the world and look what happened. That's a mess, but you'll get through it.
Here's what happened to me. I took on a group dagger board repair and had 12 Hobie 18 boards in the shop. 6 of them were coated with something other than gel and they did exactly what your boards did. 6 daggerboards!!! Done, do over! I called one of the owners to tell him that they would be another week due to a chemical reaction and he said, "Oh yeah, we coat them every year with spray paint." Dumb me for not catching it, but it'll never happen again.
Here's what to do: Hit em with acetone and a rag, get what you can. If some of the gel is stuck on well, hit it with some PVA and put them somewhere warm to kick solid. Then DA them with 80 grit and get past the coating, whatever it was. Don't be shy.
Then...
Fair the head where those casting scratches are with Formula 27, block with 80 G, Then block the whole thing with 120 and spray them with about 6 hot coats of gel.
PVA, wash, sand to 600 buff with 3m Perfectit 3 heavy cut.
Don't fret, they'll be beautiful!!
Look up my gelcoat video if you need some help. That's the right way to do it.