I used to own a 2012 Outback and have owned and ridden in numerous other Hobies/including the Compass. At the end of the day- I believe they all fish exactly the same- I never seem to catch more on any different kayak
In my opinion- the question is more of how you fish and what you bring with you. I am a casual fisherman- 2 rods max and one or two small tackle boxes. (no where near a pro) Anything in the Hobie fleet works well for me..... Once you start adding a crate/live well, Technology- 4-6 rods......... and so on.... That is where you'll see the difference.
The Compass is a great in-between boat- sufficient decking/sleek hull/stand-ability and so one. By the time you upgrade drives/add a few minor items/square hatch... your right up in price with the Outback.
The new Outback has it all + Looks
- Question is would you need to use everything it offers (primarily rear deck & added stability/weight capacity) -at what added cost & weight-
My Tandem Island used to be a beast, however now that I have my carts and loading process in place- its no heavier than any other kayak on wheels and easy to walk around. I trailer it, but park and cart it down and up from the ramps or beach.
------Once the kayak is on a cart- it weighs the same as a 40lb kayak and or a 200lb one........