some lights don't blend and the standard lighting would better provide indication of existence and proximity of another vessel
Quote:
and cannot be mistaken for any other light source,
having provided the standard lighting, it is still up to the skipper to interpret what he is saying. That would be made more difficult by a vessel showing non-standard lighting. In the instance of a light upon a sail, it is improbable that another vessle would 1) see; 2) correctly interpret until collision in immenient.
Quote:
which also indicates tack and rhum(sic) line.
Come again. Calrification required.
Quote:
No, you can't just assume you're always visible to the other boater, you still have to act responsibly.
We agree. Where we don't agree is that a handheld flashlight shone upon a sail is adequate to present a visual awareness to another vessel. I'm drawing upon my experience as previously noted.
Quote:
But nothing will prevent a collision with a speeding drunken sheriff who has no regard for human life, and is defended by a corrupt District Attorney with no knowledge of boating laws.
In mentioning that event I was trying to point out that even standard lighting is sometimes inadequate. How much so a dim light upon a sail? Make no mistake, a flashlight, no matter how bright up close, will appear as dimly lit from a distance. If our closing speed was even as little as 10 kts, at what distance would you be comfortable that I 1)saw; 2) correctly interpreted that your vessel was away from me? The sooner the better is good, but I'm asking for a specific distance because it is my experience that a light upon a sail is capable for only a small distance. And that's me being optimistic.
Quote:
On my lake, one of our club members was hit by a pontoon boat, driven by a teenage girl who was so drunk she had passed out at the wheel. The lake patrol caught up with the boat, which continued on (her friends tossing bottles off as it went), and air-lifted her to the hospital for alcohol poisoning. Neither she nor her parents were charged with any crime.