fusioneng wrote:
Here is another article comparing Hobie revo 11 to Native mariner 10 (at least this guy is trying to be honest and forthright).
I haven't see this comparison, but looking at a 2016 Slayer 13 Propel vs 2015 Hobie Outback, (very close in size and purpose) here are some very specific results (Lake Hodges, GPS and HRM (heart rate monitor -- used as a measure of work output), one hour timed runs, conditions as noted):
Hobie Outback
1. 4.54 miles, 117 BPM (beats per minute), no current, calm conditions, Turbofins
2. 4.46 miles, 117 BPM, no current, light wind and chop both directions, Turbofins
3. 4.47 miles, -- BPM, no current, very light wind both directions, Turbofins
4. 4.04 miles. 111 BPM, no current, very light wind both directions,
ST FinsNative Slayer
1. 3.94 miles, 119 BPM, no current, calm
2. 3.92 miles, 115 BPM, no current, calm
3. 3.81 miles, 111 BPM, no current, calm
Conclusions:1. The Outback (with Turbos) runs about .6 MPH faster than the Slayer under very similar water conditions and work output. The difference is consistent.
2. The Outback (
with ST fins) runs about .2 MPH faster than the Slayer
Note -- the Slayer is operating with the following factory prop in all runs:
"The Native Watercraft Propel Easy Cruz Propeller is a replacement high efficiency propeller. It optimizes pitch and rake adjustments to give the propel drive unit a 50% increase in efficiency while maintaining the same top end speed the Propel Drive is revered for."3. The Slayer is not a match for the Outback for speed under any fin or propeller condition. With Turbofins, the Slayer is slower than all hardshell Hobie Mirage Drive models.
4. The Slayer 13 fails to meet its advertised speed as quoted on the Native website for one hour, not to mention all day in an optimal no current water environment:
"So, how fast does it go? With relaxed pedaling you can cover 4.2 miles per hour all day"This is the only
documented comparison that I've seen.
