Great discussion. Lately I have been tempted to upgrade my main sheet fittings to the boom and wasn't sure of the best method so this is very timely for me.
Given the cons of the snap shackles I'm reading I'm tempted to just leave it alone and deal with regular shackles to remove the main sheet from the boom.
I have one snap shackle and the clevis pin won't go through the attachment pin (better/more accurate term?) on the block. I was faced with drilling out the hole to accept the clevis which I won't do for obvious reasons, or trying something else. Question is, what else?
If all I'm accomplishing with snap shackles is quicker/easier de-installation of the main sheet then it doesn't seem like it's worth spending the moolah just to reduce the integrity of the rig. It doesn't take that long to remove the regular shackles and there is only an upside to continue using them. Agreed?
That said, other than snap shackles are there NO other shackle options?