Hello Skyfish,
Full disclosure notice, I am the Director of Engineering at Hobie Cat and the primary designer of the i-series kayaks.
With obvious bias aside, I have done a lot of fishing from the i9, i12 and i14 kayaks catching rockfish, sculpins, whitfish, calicos, sand bass, sierra, yellowtail, bonita, trout, salmon and halibut using a variety of terminal tackle with sharp hooks. Many of these fish have sharp teeth and spines and none of them or any of the hooks have caused damage. I did puncture my starboard hull in an i9 while trying to subdue an angry halibut with a fillet knife. I thought it was the fish's air blatter that went but soon found myself listing slightly to starboard. With the fishing hot and the boat still quite seaworthy with two good compartments, I kept fishing.
If a puncture occurs in an easy-to-patch location, fixing the leak is simple and permanent. Get the area around the leak clean and dry, cut the patch to size, apply glue to the patch and the hull, wait five minutes, press the patch firmly to the hull. If it is cold and wet like it was in Alaska, use some heat to get the material soft, warm and dry. I used my MSR stove due to my isolated location. Some intense sunshine or a hairdryer is a better and safer option. Heat always makes working on PVC easier.
As far as the wet-rear issue in the i14, the rear seat will get your rear a bit soggy if you are over 180 lbs. It helps to move the seat as far forward as possible adjusting the cranks forward accordingly. Also, the front seat rides higher and will accomodate more weight. I am heavier than my wife so I usually ride up front in the i14. A boat seat cushion will lift you up enough to keep you dry in the rear seat and the boat is plenty stable to accomodate the higher seating location.
I prefer the Pro Angler when I am fishing locally but when traveling by air or long road trips, the inflatables are my boats of choice. I have great confidence in them and think you would be very happy with one.
|