Roadrunner wrote:
This could be my imagination, but it looks like your rear mast may be bent back slightly. You can check this out by comparing the distance between masts at the bases vs. at the tips when centered. This can cause similar symptoms. Another way to check is to swap the fins front to rear and see how they sit.

Yep, that's the problem. The small deformity from me pedaling out of allignment is still there on the fin, but after taking them off, I can see both fins are exactly the same shape.
The rear mast is slightly bent, I must have whacked it on something. It seems odd for the rear one to be bent instead of the front, but that's what I'm dealing with.
Nice catch, Roadrunner. It should have occurred to me to take them off and compare, I'm a dope.

Now to figure out how to unbend it.